Cakes, Cupcakes & Custom Treats
by Cupcake Mama
Custom cakes, stuffed cupcakes and edible favors baked to order by Marie Buonomo in the Freehold / Howell, NJ area.
Custom Cakes • Stuffed Cupcakes • Edible Favors
Send an InquiryOne flavor and one filling per 24 stuffed cupcakes. Weekend pickups are typically Friday 4–6 PM, with limited delivery available by request.
Holiday Cupcakes
Limited-edition holiday cupcakes available in these six festive flavors. Each dozen includes 2 of each flavor. Perfect for teacher gifts, office treats and holiday parties.
Pickup from the Freehold / Howell area with limited holiday delivery available — quantities are limited and sell out quickly, so pre-order is highly recommended.
🎄 Six Holiday Flavors 🎄
Chocolate fudge cake with hot cocoa buttercream
Chocolate chip cake with Oreo buttercream
Spiced gingerbread cake with cream cheese buttercream
Vanilla spice cake with cookie butter buttercream
Chocolate fudge cake with graham cracker buttercream
Vanilla confetti cake with sugar cookie buttercream
About Cupcake Mama
Hi, I'm Marie — the baker behind Cupcake Mama. I specialize in custom cakes, stuffed cupcakes and edible favors that are designed around your colors, theme and budget.
Everything is baked from scratch from my home kitchen on the Freehold / Howell border, with layered cakes, rich mousses and fun fillings that make every slice and every cupcake feel like its own little celebration.
Our Creations
What I Offer
🎂 Layered Cakes
Available in 6", 8", 10" and 12" sizes with your choice of layers, fillings, and icing (vanilla buttercream or fudge). Custom toppers available from ARJcrafting to match your theme perfectly.
🧁 Stuffed Cupcakes
One cake flavor and one filling per 24 cupcakes, stuffed with mousse, fudge or fruit fillings so every cupcake feels like a mini layer cake. Custom toppers available from ARJcrafting.
🍭 Edible Favors & Platters
Hot chocolate bombs, cake pops, chocolate lollipops, dipped rice Krispy pops, dipped pretzels, dipped caramel pretzels, chocolate-covered strawberries, cakesicles, brownie platters, cookie & brownie platters and chocolate-dipped Oreos.
How Ordering Works
To keep everything fresh and custom, I work by pre-order only. Here's how the process works:
Send an Inquiry
Share your event date, type of event, location, approximate servings, flavors and theme. You can email me at [email protected], text or call 732-766-6933.
Get a Quote & Design Plan
I'll confirm availability, suggest sizes and flavors, and go over design ideas (colors, theme, style and budget).
Secure Your Date
A 50% non-refundable deposit via Venmo is required to hold your spot on the calendar.
Last-Minute Orders
Orders booked 10 days or less before the event require 100% non-refundable payment in advance via Venmo or Zelle.
Pickup or Delivery
Pickup is from my home kitchen near the Freehold / Howell border (exact address provided upon booking). Weekend orders are typically picked up Friday between 4–6 PM, or by arrangement the day/evening prior. Delivery is available for an additional fee when scheduled in advance.
Payment Options
Secure your order with Venmo @Marie-Coloreo or Zelle 732-766-6933. A 50% deposit is required to hold your date. Last-minute orders (10 days or less) require 100% payment upfront.
Menu & Flavors
Cake & Cupcake Flavors
- Chocolate
- Vanilla
- Lemon
- Lemon Poppy
- Red Velvet
- Spice
- Pumpkin
- Carrot
- Tinted Vanilla
- Confetti
- Banana
- Coconut
- Cinnamon
- Pistachio
Cereal Cupcakes: Fruity Pebbles, Cocoa Pebbles, Apple Jacks and more baked right into the cake.
Standard Fillings
- Chocolate Mousse
- Vanilla Mousse
- Lemon Mousse
- Lemon Mascarpone
- Fudge
- White Chocolate Confetti
- Cheesecake Mousse
- Strawberry
- Banana Mousse
- Raspberry
- Blueberry
- Peach
- Cookies n Cream
- Cookie Butter Mousse
- Peanut Butter Mousse
- Coconut Mousse
- Cinnamon Spice
- Pumpkin
- Chocolate Cinnamon
- Pistachio Mousse
- Tiramisu
Premium Fillings
- Cookie Dough ($)
- Cannoli ($)
- Nutella Fudge ($)
- Dulce de Leche ($)
✨ Popular Flavor Pairings ✨
Vanilla cake + Strawberry or Raspberry filling
Chocolate cake + Fudge or Chocolate Mousse filling
Lemon cake + Lemon Mousse or Lemon Mascarpone
Vanilla or Chocolate + Cookies n Cream filling
Red Velvet cake + Cheesecake Mousse filling
Carrot cake + Cinnamon Spice filling
These are customer favorites, but feel free to mix and match any cake with any filling!
Cupcakes & Cakes – Pricing
Core pricing for custom cupcakes and layered cakes:
Final pricing will vary based on flavors, fillings, decorations and theme. You'll receive a detailed quote once you submit your inquiry.
Treats & Favors – Starting Prices
Pricing will vary based on theme and decorations, but here are starting prices for popular treats:
Custom cakes and stuffed cupcakes are quoted individually based on servings and design. You'll receive a detailed quote once you submit your inquiry.
Ready to Order?
Let's bring your vision to life! Fill out the quick form below or contact me directly.
Or contact me directly: